Lilian Bermejo Luque

Transcripción

1 Lilian Bermejo Luque Institute of Philosophy Spanish National Research Council, CCHS-CSIC Albasanz, Madrid, Spain AREAS OF SPECIALISATION Argumentation Theory, Theories of Rationality, Theory of Judgment AREAS OF COMPETENCE Philosophy of Language, Epistemology, Philosophy of Logic, Metaethics EDUCATION : PhD in Philosophy. European Doctor- First class honours, highest possible mark for the thesis Faculty of Philosophy, University of Murcia Thesis: Bases Filosóficas para una Teoría Normativa de la Argumentación. Hacia un Enfoque Unificado de sus Dimensiones Lógica, Dialéctica y Retórica Thesis Supervisors: E. G. Fernández Díez-Picazo & F. H. van Eemeren 2003: Master in Philosophy Faculty of Philosophy, University of Murcia First class honours in coursework; highest possible mark for the thesis Specialisation: Logic, Philosophy of Language, Aesthetics, Moral Philosophy and Epistemology, Master Thesis: El Estudio de la Falacia y su lugar en la Lógica Informal Supervisor: M. Hernández : BA (Hons) in Philosophy Faculty of Philosophy, University of Murcia First class honours in coursework APPOINTMENTS Previous appointments /1997 Undergraduate Teaching Assistant. ( Alumna Interna and Becaria de Colaboración ) Teacher of Philosophy at higher schools Pre-doctoral researcher at the University of Murcia Post-doctoral researcher at the Department of Logic, History and Philosophy of Science, UNED, Madrid. Current major appointments Today: JAE-Doc Research Fellowship, Institute of Philosophy, Department of Theoretical Philosophy, CCHS-CSIC Today: Member of the Master Filosofía Práctica y Teórica, of the Faculty of Philosophy of the UNED

2 Today: Member of the Master Filosofía Contemporánea, of the Department of Philosophy I. Universidad de Granada Today: Member of the Master Crítica y Argumentación Filosófica, of the Faculty of Philosophy. Universidad Autónoma de Madrid. Grants and Funding FPU Scholarship of the Spanish Ministry of Education and Science Juan de la Cierva Research Fellowship of the Spanish Ministry of Education and Science JAE-Doc Research Fellowship of the CSIC - May-July 2010 Visiting Scholar in the Department of Speech Communication, Argumentation Theory and Rhetoric, University of Amsterdam Several grants to attend to international conferences by the Fundación Séneca, the University of Murcia, the Spanish Ministry of Education and Science and the CSIC Participant in two international research projects financed by the Spanish Ministry of Science Visiting Scholar in the Department of Speech Communication, Argumentation Theory and Rhetoric. University of Amsterdam TEACHING AND SUPERVISION Courses Taught - Year 05/06 Curso de Metalógica. Los Límites de los Sistemas Formales. Graduate. University of Murcia - Year 06/07 Curso Monográfico de Filosofía del Lenguaje. Teorías del Signficado. Graduate. University of Murcia - Year 07/08 Historia de la Lógica, Argumentación y Análisis del Discurso. Graduate. La Pragma-dialéctica. Master. UNED - Year 08/09 Historia de la Lógica, Argumentación y Análisis del Discurso. Graduate. Teorías de la Racionalidad. Master. UNED - Year 09/10 Teorías de la Racionalidad. Master. UNED. Argumentación Filosófica. Master. University of Granada - Year 10/11 Teorías de la Racionalidad. Master. UNED. Argumentación Filosófica. Master. University of Granada. Políticas del Arte. Argumentación y Juicio Estético. Master. Universidad Complutense de Madrid Students Supervised PhD Students (Current) Juan Gonzalo Lerma Peláez. Title: Semejanzas y Diferencias: el Estudio de la Argumentación Analógica en el Periodo Pre-Han MPhil (Current) Alejandro Secades. Provisional Title: Formas de Argumentación en la Cultura Aymara. Master student in the UNED. PUBLICATIONS Books - Bases Filosóficas para una Teoría Normativa Integral de la Argumentación. Hacia un Enfoque Unificado de sus Dimensiones Lógica, Dialéctica y Retórica. PhD Thesis, online publication: - Giving Reasons. A Linguistic Approach To Argumentation Theory. Springer: Dordrecht (In Press, summer 2011)

3 - Argumentos y Falacias. Una Introducción a la Teoría de la Argumentación. In preparation (expected by the end 2011) Articles Filosofía y retórica: el lugar de la teoría de la argumentación, in Daimon. Revista de Filosofía, vol. 30/I Toulmin s Model of Argument and the Question of Relativism, in Informal Logic, vol. 24/II Escepticismo y deductivismo, in Daimon, revista de Filosofía, vol 36/II Logic as (Normative) Inference Theory: Formal vs. Non-Formal Theories of Inference Goodness, in Informal Logic, vol 28/IV Argumentation Theory and the Conception of Epistemic Justification, in Studies in Logic, Rhetoric and Grammar, vol 15 (28) La Distinción Aristotélica entre Lógica, Dialéctica y Retórica y su Lugar en la Teoría de la Argumentación, in Cogency, Journal of Reasoning and Argumentation, vol 1/II Second Order Intersubjectivity: The Dialectical Aspect of Argumentation, in Argumentation, vol 24/I Intrinsic vs. Instrumental Values of Argumentation. The Rhetorical Dimension of Argumentation, in Argumentation, Vol 24/IV (Coo-authored with Antonio Casado da Rocha) Bancos, bibliotecas y cementerios: usos de las analogías y las clasificaciones en el razonamiento sobre biotecnología, en Theoria (In press, expected May 2011) Book Chapters Toulmin s Model of Argument and the Question of Relativism, In Arguing on the Toulmin s Model: New Essays in Argument Analysis and Evaluation, D. Hitchcock and B. Verheij, Eds Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht The Normativity of Argumentation as a Justificatory and as a Persuasive Device, In Contemporary Perspectives On Argumentation, F. H. van Eemeren, M. D. Hazen, P. Houtlosser, D. C. Williams, Eds SicSat, Amsterdam La Concepción Retórica del Valor de la Argumentación, in Estudios en Argumentación y Retórica. Teorías Contemporáneas y Aplicaciones. C. Santibáñez y B. Riffo, Eds Universidad de Concepción, Santiago de Chile The Ad Baculum as a Fallacy: False vs. Bad Argumentation, in Understanding Argumentation. F. H. van Eemeren, D. C. Williams, I. Z. Zagar, Eds SicSat- Rozemberg, Amsterdam La Apelación Ad Baculum como Falacia: Falsa versus Mala Argumentación, in De las Falacias. Argumentación y Comunicación. C. Santibáñez y R. Marafioti, Eds Biblos, Buenos Aires El Programa Filosófico de The Uses of Argument, in C. Santibáñez y R. Marafioti, Eds., Biblos, Buenos Aires Several entries in Diccionario de Argumentación. Trotta: Madrid. (2010) Por qué argumentar y porqué hacerlo bien, in L. Vega y G. Bolado, Eds. Ediciones del Parlamento de Cantabria, Santander Publications in Peer-Reviewed Conference Proceedings Rhetorical Criteria for Argument Evaluation?, in Proceedings of The II Tokyo Conference On Argumentation, T. Suzuki, Ed. Tsuda Publications, Tokyo, Dealing with Enthymemes, in Critical Problems in Argumentation: Proceedings of the Thirteenth NCA/AFA Conference on Argumentation, Charles A. Willard, Ed. Washington, DC: National Communication Association

4 Toulmin s Model of Argument and the Question of Relativism, in 2005 OSSA Confererence on Argumentation, D. Hitchcock, Ed. McMaster University Press Services, Hamilton, La Concepción Toulmiana de la Lógica como Teoría No-Formal de la Validez, in Actas del V Congreso de la Sociedad de Lógica, Metodología y Filosofía de la Ciencia en España. F. Martínez Manrique y L.M. Peris-Viñé, Ed. Ediciones Sider, Granada, The Justification of the Normative Nature of Argumentation Theory, in Proceedings of the 2006 ISSA Conference. F.H. van Eemeren, A.J. Blair and C.A. Willard, Eds. SicSat, Amsterdam Second Order Intersubjectivity: The Dialectical Aspect of Argumentation, Dissensus & The Search for Common Ground: Proceedings of the Seventh OSSA Conference on Argumentation. CD-Rom Windsor, Ontario 2008 Response To Hitchcock, Dissensus & The Search for Common Ground: Proceedings of the Seventh OSSA Conference on Argumentation. CD-Rom Windsor, Ontario, 2008 Rhetorical Meaning vs. Rhetorical Import, Cultures of Argument: Proceedings of the Eighth OSSA Conference on Argumentation. CD-Rom Windsor, Ontario, 2009 On Goodwin s The Authority Of Wikipedia, Cultures Of Argument: Proceedings Of The Eighth Ossa Conference On Argumentation. Cd-Rom Windsor, Ontario, 2009 Response to B. Gaarsen, Cultures of Argument: Proceedings of the Eighth OSSA Conference On Argumentation. CD-Rom Windsor, Ontario, 2009 A Linguistic Pragmatic Reconstruction of Toulmin s Model of Argument, in Actas del VI Congreso de la Sociedad de Lógica, Filosofía y Metodología de la Ciencia. Valencia, 2009, Contributed Papers to International Conferences Dealing with enthymemes, XIII SCA/AFA Alta Conference on Argumentation. Alta, Utah, 31 July 2003 The role of Rhetoric withing argumentation theory, II International Workshop on Semantics, Pragmatics and Rhetoric, ILCLI. Donostia, San Sebastián. 6 November 2003 Rhetorical Criteria for Argument Evaluation?, II Tokyo Conference on Argumentation. Tsuda Collage. Tokyo, 03 August La Evaluación e Interpretación de los Entimemas, VII Inter-Universitary Workshop in Philosophy. Universidad de Valencia. Valencia, 10 January Toulmin s Model And The Question Of Relativism, 2005 OSSA Conference on Argumentation. McMaster University, Hamilton. 20 May The Justification of the Normative Status of Argumentation Theory s Models, ISSA Conference on Argumentation. University of Amsterdam. Amsterdam, 24 June Bad Vs. False Argumentation: The Cases Of The Ad Baculum And The Ad Carotam, I Koper International Conference On Argumentation. Universidad De Koper. Koper, 26 November Second Order Intersubjectivity: The Dialectical Aspect Of Argumentation, 2007 OSSA Conference on Argumentation. University of Windsor. Windsor, Ontario 08 June Response To Hitchcock, 2007 OSSA Conference on Argumentation. University of Windsor, Windsor, Ontario, 06 June The Pragmatic Account of Argumentative Value, III International Conference on Axiology. Universidad de Alcalá de Henares. Alcalá de Henares, 08 July Rhetorical Meaning vs. Rhetorical Import, 2009 OSSA Conference on Argumentation, University of Windsor, Windsor, Ontario, 05 June 09. On Goodwin s The Authority Of Wikipedia, 2009 OSSA Conference on Argumentation, University of Windsor, Windsor, Ontario, 06 June 09

5 Sentimentalism and Relativism, I Workshop on Ethics and the Emotions, Universidad de Salamanca, Salamanca, 3 March10. Warrants and motivations to infer: the case of moral judgments, 2010 ISSA Conference. University of Amsterdam. Amsterdam, Reviews Several reviews in Daimon (2006), Teorema (2007), Isegoría (2010) PRESENTATIONS, TALKS, KEYNOTE SPEECHES Invited Speaker in International Conferences and Events Invited speaker in the Research Colloquium of the Research Group Argumentation in Discourse of the Department of Argumentation, Speech Communication and Rhetoric of the University of Amsterdam. Title: Argumentation Theory in Aristotle. 4 April 2004, Amsterdam, The Netherlands. Invited to participate and deliver a lecture in the XII Venice Conference on Argumentation, organized by the Department of Speech Communication of the Wake Forest University. Title: The Normativity of Argumentation as a Justificatory and as a Persuasive Device July 2004, Venice, Italy. This is an invitation only forum for scholars from one and the other side of the Atlantic to exchange ideas about Argumentation Studies. Keynote speech with two commentators in the AILACT Group Session of the Annual Meeting of the American Philosophical Association. Title: The Relationship between Reasoning and Arguing, 25 March 2005, San Francisco, CA. Invited speaker in the Symposium on Argumentation of the II Congreso Iberoamericano de Filosofía de la Ciencia y la Tecnología. University of La Laguna. Title: El Razonamiento y la Argumentación. 10 September 2005, Tenerife, Spain. Invited speaker in the Symposium on Argumentation of the V Congreso de la Sociedad de Lógica, Metodología y Filosofía de la Ciencia en España. Title: Toulmin s Conception of Logic as Non-Formal Theory of Validity. 30 November 2006, Granada, Spain. Invited speaker in the XIV Congreso Internacional de Filosofía de la Asociación Filosófica de México. Title: El Valor de la Argumentación: Justificación o Racionalidad. 5 November 2007, Mazatlán, Mexico. Invited speaker in the Meeting of the Inter-University International Network Construyendo Europa: Tradición, Valores y Nueva Ciudadanía. CSIC. Title: De la Tolerancia a La Fraternidad: la Función Social de la Argumentación 17 June 2008, Madrid, Spain. Invited speaker in the, Symposium on Argumentation VI Congreso de la Sociedad de Lógica, Metodología y Filosofía de la Ciencia. Title: A Linguistic Pragmatic Reconstruction of Toulmin s Model of Argument. 20 November 2009, Valencia, Spain. Invited Speaker in Seminars and Workshops Escepticismo y Deductivismo, IX Semana de Filosofía de la SFRM. University of Murcia. 22 Febreary 2005 Normatividad Argumentativa, I Workshop on Argumentation. University of Valencia, 12 May 2006 La Justificación del Estatus Normativo de los Modelos de Teoría de la Argumentación, Seminar on Argumentación. UNED. Madrid, 14 March 2007

6 La Relación entre Razonamiento y Argumentación, Seminar of the Instituto de Investigaciones Filosóficas. UNAM. México D.F., 12 November 2007 Retóricas de la Imagen, keynote speech for the Lectures Session Las Estaciones Sonoras of the Molina de Segura Council. Murcia, 07 February 2008 Racionalidad Teórica y Racionalidad Práctica. La Legitimidad de la Argumentación como Medio de Influencia, Summer School. UNED. Santander, 8 September 2008 The Logical, Dialectical and Rhetorical Dimensions of Communication, a whole workshop invited by the University of Koper. Slovenia April 2009 Las Dimensiones Lógica, Dialéctica y Retórica de la Argumentación, Summer School, UNED, Santander July 2009 Argumentation as a Second Order Speech Act Complex, I Workshop on Argumentation, Instituto de Filosofía. UNAM. México DF. 24 September 09. La Justificación de las Teorías Normativas, Seminar. UNED. Madrid 25 September Fundamentos Lógicos y Argumentativos del Juicio Estético, Seminar on Perception and Aesthetic Judgment. CCHS-CSIC. 29 April 2010 Persuadir y Justificar Apelando a Valores, Seminar of JuriLog. CSIC. Madrid. 18 March 2010 ORGANIZATION, COMMITTEES, BOARDS, PRIZES Debate Team Manager for the Contest Foroidea, by CajaMadrid Foundational member and treasurer of the Sociedad de Filosofía de la Región de Murcia - Winner of the 2005 Blair Essay Prize to the best graduate student paper. - Chair at the 2006 ISSA Conference. Amsterdam. June Chair at the I Slovenia International Conference on Argumentation. Koper, November Chair at the II Slovenia International Conference on Argumentation. Ljubljana, April Chair at the 2009 OSSA Conference on Argumentation. Windsor, ON. June Chair at the 2010 ISSA Conference on Argumentation. Amsterdam, July Organizer of the Seminar on Normativity in the Department of Logic, History and Philosophy of Science, UNED. Madrid, May Co-organizer of the I International Workshop on Perception and Aesthetic Judgment. CSIC. Madrid, Academic Year 09/10. Referee for Scholarly Journals - Journal Informal Logic, University of Windsor - Journal Crítica, Institute of Philosophy of the Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México - Journal The Philosophical Quarterly of Israel Boards and Comitees - Secretary of Revista Iberoamericana de Argumentación, UNED - Member of the Editorial board of Cogency. Journal of Reasoning and Argumentation, Universidad Diego Portales, Chile - Member of the Editorial board of Topoi, Springer Societies Membership - Internacional Society for the Study of Argumentation (ISSA) - Association for Informal Logic and Critical Thinking (AILACT) - Ontario Society for the Study of Argumentation (OSSA) MEDIA

7 1. Videos for the Parliament of Cantabria. UNED Summer Course on Argumentation and Rhetoric for the Members of the Parliament of Cantabria: