First Wines of Argentina Awards - the results

Transcripción

1 Written by Jancis Robinson 26 Feb 2007 First Wines of Argentina Awards - the results See also How good are Argentine wines today? Here is the full list of medal winners in the first Wines of Argentina Awards which I judged in Mendoza last week and which spawned my week of blogs. The trophies were awarded on the third day of the competition by having all 12 judges taste all gold medal-winning wines blind and individually and combining their marks except where there was only one gold medal as in the Blanc and White Blend categories. Thus, I can work out which wine was which in the smaller categories such as Sparkling Wine and Torrontés (I preferred the richer Colomé example to the trophy-winning more sculpted one from the much larger Lavaque group). The trophy categories were, in descending order, Sparkling Wine, Blanc, Torrontés, White Blends, Tempranillo, Red Blends, Cabernet, and Syrah. Producers, however big, were only allowed to enter five wines from each of their bodegas. Companies that seem to have done particularly well in terms of golds and trophies are the Austrian-owned Norton, the giant Peñaflor's subsidiaries Trapiche and Santa Ana, the French-owned Domaine Vistalba (Fabre Montmayou in Mendoza and Infinitus in Patagonia) and Callia in San Juan (the estate sold by Carlos Pulenta to Salentein of Mendoza who also own El Portillo). Carlos Pulenta now has his own very smart Mendoza winery to make Tormero and (confusingly) Finca y Bodega Vistalba labels and operates quite separately from his brothers

2 who run Pulenta Estate, which also did pretty well in the Awards. Note that any name with an SA or sa after it is a limited company. Of the golds and trophy winners, Zuccardi is a particularly well established family company; Lavaque is one of the bigger companies with enterprises in many of Argentina's wine regions; Luigi Bosca is run by the Arizu family; Tittarelli is an old firm but now part of an investment group and I have to say that I was not a great fan of the trophy-winning Tempranillo myself; Don Domenico is a newish Italian/Argentine company; Cave Extrême buys in grapes for champenisation and is run by the man who used to run the Chandon sparkling wine enterprise that has been doing a sterling job in Argentina for decades (sister company to Terrazas de los Andes for still wines which did reasonably well in the Awards); Colomé is run by Swiss art collector Donald Hess who also owns the Hess Collection in Napa Valley, Peter Lehmann in Australia and Glen Carlou in South Africa; Valentin Bianchi is one of the old Argentine bodegas with some outside investors nowadays; Tamari is new and Chilean-owned (the big Argentine outpost of Chile's giant Concha y Toro) which picked up a few silvers and bronzes; Fournier is the Spanish-owned Tempranillo specialist (A-crux is a blend based on this Spanish grape); Doña Paula is owned by San Pedro of Chile; Dominio del Plata is the small outfit run by Susana Balbo, dynamic head of Wines of Argentina and her viticulturist husband Pedro Marchevsky; and Enrique Foster is a small producer concentrating on old-vine owned by a Spaniard resident in the US. This international mix is entirely representative of Argentina. Gold Trophy Familia Zuccardi Alma 4 Chardonnay Roble Gold Trophy Pulenta Estate La Flor de Pulenta Estate Blanc Gold Trophy Bodega Felix Lavaque SA Quara Torrontés Gold Trophy Bodega Luigi Bosca Luigi Bosca Gala 3 Viognier Gold Trophy Tittarelli VOSA (Part of Agroamerican Group sa) Reserva Especial Tempranillo Gold Trophy Bodega Norton SA Norton Privada

3 Gold Trophy Bodegas Santa Ana La Mascota Cabernet Gold Trophy Domaine Vistalba SA Fabre Montmayou Fabre Montmayou Gran Reserva Gold Trophy Winery Don Domenico SA Finca Don Domenico de Huanacache Syrah Gold Cave Extrême Extrême Méthode Champenoise NV Gold Bodega Colome sa Colome Torrontes Gold Bodegas Callia Grand Callia Gold Valentin Bianchi sacif Enzo Bianchi Gold Domaine Vistalba SA Infinitus Infinitus Syrah Gold Bodega Tamarí sa Tamarí - Cabernet Reserve Gold Eral Bravo Winery Eral Bravo YBS Gold Bodega Norton SA Norton Perdriel Single Vineyard Gold Bodegas Callia Callia Magna Shiraz Gold O. Fournier SA Alfa Crux Blend 2001 Gold Viña Doña Paula Doña Paula Estate Seleccion de Bodega Gold Dominio del Plata Susana Balbo Gold Bodega Trapiche Trapiche Single Vineyard Viña Pedro Gonzalez Gold Bodega Trapiche Trapiche Single Vineyard Viña Victorio Coletto

4 Gold Bodega Enrique Foster Enrique Foster Reserva Finca Castro Barros Trivento Bodegas y Viñedos SA Trivento Sparkling Extra Brut NV Ovalles-Muñoz srl Ovalles & Muñoz Chardonnay - Chenin Finca y Bodega Vistalba Tomero Blanc Bodega El Portillo Finca El Portillo Blanc Nomade Wines and Vineyards Bodegas El Porvenir de Los Andes Nomade Torrontés Laborum Torrontés Viños de Los Andes Los Quimiles La Riojana Cooperative Vitivinifruticola de La Rioja Ltda Ramirez de Velazco Familia Schroeder - Patagonia Saurus Patagonia Select Chardonnay Bodegas Esmeralda sa (Argento) Argento Chardonnay Finca Las Moras Las Moras Reserve Chardonnay Bodega del Fin del Mundo - Patagonia Reserva del Fin del Mundo Chardonnay Pulenta Estate Pulenta Estate Chardonnay Monteviejo sa Lindaflor Chardonnay Bodegas Santa Ana Santa Ana Viognier Reserve La Riojana Cooperative Vitivinifruticola de La Rioja Ltda Estampilla Torrontés - Blanc

5 Bodegas Etchart Etchart Torrontés Tardio Valentin Bianchi sacif Familia Bianchi Late Harvest Trivento Bodegas y Viñedos SA Parra Alta Rosé Bodega Catena Zapata Alamos Pinot Noir Familia Schroeder - Patagonia Saurus Patagonia Select Merlot Viña Doña Paula Doña Paula Estate Merlot Bodega RJ Viñedos Joffré e Hijas Premium Merlot Bodegas Callia Callia Magna Tannat Pulenta Estate Pulenta Gran Cabernet Franc Trivento Bodegas y Viñedos SA Trivento Reserve Syrah- Bodega Colome sa Amalaya O. Fournier SA Urban Uco Blend Bodega Norton SA Norton Privada Telteca Winery (Viñas Argentinas sa) Telteca Gran Reserva Grappolo sa (Bressia) Bressia Conjuro Bodega del Fin del Mundo - Patagonia Special Blend Andeluna Cellars srl Andeluna Gran Reserva Pasionado Finca La Celia SA Supremo 2002 Monte Quieto Quieto Bodega Antigal sa Cavia Reserve

6 RPB sa - Baggio Bodega Privada Domaine Jean Bousquet Jean Bousquet Tupungato Finca Los Maza ( Maza Tonconogy SRL) Finca Los Maza Reserva Roca sa Alfredo Roca Family Reserve Bodega Navarro Correas Alegoría Cabernet Sauvigon Bodega Ruca Malen SA Ruca Malen Cabernet Bodega Tapiz Zolo Cabernet Andeluna Cellars srl Andeluna Cabernet Reserva Eral Bravo Winery Eral Bravo Cabernet Terrazas de los Andes Afincado Cabernet Bodegas San Huberto San Huberto Crianza Bodega Felix Lavaque SA Bodega NQN - Viñedos de la Patagonia srl Quara Reserva Malma Clasico Finca Flichman Misterio Familia Zuccardi Santa Julia Bodega Antigal sa Cavia Familia Schroeder - Patagonia Saurus Patagonia Select Cabernet

7 Bodega del Fin del Mundo - Patagonia Reserva del Fin del Mundo Cabernet Bodega NQN - Viñedos de la Patagonia srl Malma Clasico Cabernet Michel Torino Wines Michel Torino Don David Cabernet Cavas del 23 srl Imperio de los Sentidos Cabernet Finca Lunlunta SA La Chamiza Polo Profesional Cabernet Pascual Toso sa Pascual Toso Cabernet Reserva Viña Doña Paula Doña Paula Estate Freixenet Argentina sa Viento Sur Telteca Winery (Viñas Argentinas sa) Telteca Oak Andeluna Cellars srl Andeluna Reserva Viñedos y Bodega Tempus Alba/Aldo Luis Biondolillo y Asociados sa Tempus Terrazas de los Andes Terrazas Reserva Bodega Melipal Melipal Chakana Estate (Proviva srl) Chakana Reserve Trivento Bodegas y Viñedos SA Trivento Amado Sur Viña Qaramy Qaramy Pachahuasi Finca y Bodega Vistalba Vistalba Corte C

8 Bodegas Etchart Arnaldo B. Etchart Cellarworld Argentina Casa Puel 'Solares' Dominio del Plata BenMarco Expresivo Viña Qaramy Qaramy Qailapuyu Rutini Wines Felipe Rutini Encuentro Familia Zuccardi Zuccardi Zeta Monteviejo sa Monteviejo Finca Las Moras Mora Negra Tittarelli VOSA (Part of Agroamerican Group sa) Viñedos y Bodega Tempus Alba/Aldo Luis Biondolillo y Asociados sa Bodega del 900 Tempus Pleno Bodega Luigi Bosca Finca La Linda Valentin Bianchi sacif Familia Bianchi Bodegas Salentein Salentein Reserve Bodega Nieto Senetiner Reserva Nieto Senetiner Bodegas Viñas de Altura sa Rincon Privado Kaiken SA Kaiken Ultra Dominio del Plata BenMarco Chakana Estate (Proviva srl) Trivento Bodegas y Viñedos SA Chakana Syrah Otra Vida Shiraz Viña Doña Paula Doña Paula Estate Shiraz

9 Familia Zuccardi Santa Julia Reserva Syrah Bodegas Santa Ana Santa Ana Shiraz Reserve Valle de la Puerta La Puerta Reserva Syrah Bodega Felix Lavaque SA Xumek - Santa Sylvia sa Quara Syrah XumeK Bodega Septima Septima Familia Blanco Mairena Bodega Dante Robino Gran Dante Robino DOC Bodega Tapiz Tapiz Reserva Bodega Navarro Correas Alegoría Lagarde SA Lagarde Reserve Trivento Bodegas y Viñedos SA Trivento Golden Reserve Bodega y Viñedos Renacer sa Finca y Bodega Vistalba Renacer Reserva Tomero Bodega Luigi Bosca Luigi Bosca Reserva O. Fournier SA Urban Uco Nomade Wines and Vineyards Nomade Bodega Norton SA Norton Reserva Familia Zuccardi Zuccardi Q

10 Bodegas Salentein Numina Bodega Norton SA Norton Perdriel Single Vineyard Bodega Colome sa Colome Reserva Cheval des Andes Cheval des Andes 2002 Dominio del Plata Susana Balbo Brioso O. Fournier SA O. Fournier SA Alfa Crux Blend 2002 B Crux Blend Bodega Noemia de Patagonia sa J. Alberto Marton Andina Serrera Gran Guarda Pulenta Estate Pulenta Gran Finca Sophenia SA Sophenia Synthesis Eral Bravo Winery Eral Bravo Valentin Bianchi sacif Particular Bianchi Bodega Luigi Bosca Luigi Bosca Gala 1 Nomade Wines and Vineyards Familia Marguery Casa Vinicola Nomade Reserva Familia Marguery Terrazas de los Andes Afincado Poesia sa Clos des Andes Mendel Mendel Vinorum srl Vinorum Reserve Trivento Bodegas y Viñedos SA Bastiana 1561

11 Establecimientos Vitivinicolas Escorihuela Candela Syrah Don Cristobal Cristobal Oak Reserve Syrah Monteviejo sa Lindaflor J & F Lurton Argentina Piedra Negra Val de Flores sa Val de Flores Bodega Nieto Senetiner Cadus Bodega Luigi Bosca Luigi Bosca DOC Finca Lunlunta SA La Chamiza Martín Alsina Bodega RJ Viñedos Joffré e Hijas Premium Bodega y Viñedos Renacer sa Renacer Bodega Enrique Foster Enrique Foster Limited Edition O. Fournier SA Alfa Crux Bodega Catena Zapata Catena Viñas Altamira Proemio Wines Proemio Reserve Pascual Toso sa Magdalena Toso 2002 Cave Extrême Ixdream NV Pascual Toso sa Toso Sparkling Wine Brut NV Familia Zuccardi Vida Organica Sparkling Chardonnay Bodegas Balbi Balbi Sparking Brut

12 Casa Vinícola Reyter Casa Vinícola Reyter Pascual Toso sa Extra Toso Pinot Noir NV Bodega Tapiz Tapiz Blanc Trivento Bodegas y Viñedos SA Trivento Tribu Blanc Telteca Winery (Viñas Argentinas sa) Telteca Blanc Andean Vineyards Finca La Escondida Blanc Bodegas Salentein Salentein Blanc Familia Schroeder - Patagonia Saurus Patagonia Select Blanc La Riojana Cooperative Vitivinifruticola de La Rioja Ltda Argentine Pinot Grigio - Fairtrade Santiago Graffigna Bodegas Esmeralda sa (Argento) Graffigna Pinot Grigio Argento Pinot Grigio Finca La Celia SA La Consulta Pinot Grigio Bodegas Etchart Etchart Privado Torrontés O. Fournier SA Urban Uco Torrontés Dominio del Plata Crios Torrontés Bodegas Esmeralda sa (Argento) Argento Reserva Torrontés Michel Torino Wines Michel Torino Don David Torrontés Viña Funcación de Mendoza SA Fundación de Mendoza Torrontés Prestigio

13 La Riojana Cooperative Vitivinifruticola de La Rioja Ltda Viñedos de la Posada - Fairtrade Organic Torrontés Bodegas Viñas de Altura sa Rincon Privado Torrontés J & F Lurton Argentina Flor de Torrontés Bodega Tapiz Zolo Torrontés La Riojana Cooperative Vitivinifruticola de La Rioja Ltda Raza Argentina Premium Torrontés Finca Lunlunta SA La Chamiza Polo Amateur Chardonnay RPB sa - Baggio Bodega Privada Chardonnay Bodega Trapiche Trapiche Broquel Chardonnay Bodega Antigal sa Cavia Reserve Chardonnay Viñedos Pie de Palo sa Avanti Chardonnay Domaine Jean Bousquet Jean Bousquet Tupungato Chardonnay Terrazas de los Andes Terrazas Reserva Chardonnay J & F Lurton Argentina Chardonnay Reserva Pascual Toso sa Pascual Toso Chardonnay Bodegas San Huberto San Huberto Crianza Chardonnay Trivento Bodegas y Viñedos SA Trivento Viognier Don Cristobal Cristobal 1492 Verdelho Bodegas San Huberto Velazco Torrontés- Chadonnay

14 Domaine Vistalba SA Infinitus Infinitus Chardonnay Semillon Bodega Nieto Senetiner Don Nicador Viognier - Chardonnay Andean Vineyards Elementos Chardonnay Viognier Finca La Celia SA La Celia Chardonnay Viognier Familia Zuccardi Malamado Andean Vineyards Elementos Shiraz Rosé Familia Zuccardi Santa Julia Syrah Rosé Bodega Trapiche Trapiche Rosé Finca Sophenia SA Altosur Rosé Viñas del Adagio SA Brumales Clasico Rosé Cellarworld Argentina Caitec Pinot Noir Familia Schroeder - Patagonia Saurus Patagonia Select Pinot Noir Pulenta Estate Pulenta Estate Pinot Noir Bodega Luigi Bosca Finca La Linda Tempranillo Viña Funcación de Mendoza SA Fundación de Mendoza Tempranillo Prestigio Familia Zuccardi Zuccardi Q Tempranillo Roca sa Alfredo Roca Family Reserve Tempranillo Bodega del Fin del Mundo - Patagonia Reserva del Fin del Mundo Merlot Bodega NQN - Viñedos de la Patagonia srl Malma Reserva Merlot

15 Trivento Bodegas y Viñedos SA Los Portones Bodega Antigal sa Cavia Reserve Merlot Bodega Tapiz Tapiz Merlot Andeluna Cellars srl Andeluna Merlot Bodega Norton SA Norton Merlot Reserva Bodegas Salentein Salentein Reserve Merlot Valle de la Puerta La Puerta Reserva Bonarda Familia Zuccardi Santa Julia Reserva Bonards Familia Zuccardi Zuccardi Reserva Bonarda Andean Vineyards Vino Arroyo Bonarda Familia Blanco Mairena Bonarda Michel Torino Wines Michel Torino Coleccion Finca Las Moras Las Moras Reserve Cabernet - Shiraz Seleccion Vinea sa Pasodoble Bodega Nieto Senetiner Don Nicador (blend) Bodega Tacuil 'RD' Michel Torino Wines Michel Torino Ciclos Clos de los Siete Clos de Los Siete Bodega Felix Lavaque SA Felix Lavaque De Los Clop Bodegas & Viñedos Black Bird Bonarda- Viñedos Pie de Palo sa Avanti Shiraz-

16 Bodegas Callia Callia Alto Shiraz Caviar Bleu sa Yepun Chakana Estate (Proviva srl) Chakana Estate Selection Finca Flichman Paisaje de Tupungato Bodega y Viñedos Renacer sa Renacer Clasico Familia Zuccardi Santa Julia Reserva Bodega y Viñedos San Polo sa Auka Familia Zuccardi Zuccardi Reserva Bodega El Portillo Finca El Portillo Chakana Estate (Proviva srl) Chakana La Riojana Cooperative Vitivinifruticola de La Rioja Ltda Viñedos de la Posada - Fairtrade Organic Bodegas San Huberto Velazco Santiago Graffigna Graffigna Bodegas Etchart Etchart Privado Valle de la Puerta La Puerta Viñedos Pie de Palo sa Avanti Vinorum srl Vinorum Premium Viñas del Adagio SA Adagio Reserve Vitícola Los Sauces srl Finca Urquiza 2002 Bodega El Portillo El Portillo Elevado Cabernet

17 Bodega Trapiche Trapiche Oak Cask Cabernet Bodega Trapiche Trapiche Broquel Cabernet Kaiken SA Kaiken Ultra Cabernet Finca y Bodega Vistalba Tomero Cabernet Bodega Luigi Bosca Luigi Bosca Cabernet Reserva Terrazas de los Andes Terrazas Reserva Cabernet Bodega Familia Adrover Familia Adrover Don Sebastian Bodega Trapiche Trapiche Medalla Michel Torino Wines Michel Torino Don David La Riojana Cooperative Vitivinifruticola de La Rioja Ltda Zapapico Oak Aged Cellarworld Argentina Jelu Santiago Graffigna Graffigna Centenario Chañarmuyo Estate Chañarmuyo Estate Bodega del Fin del Mundo - Patagonia Newen Bodega Humberto Canale Canale Black River Reserve Bodega del Fin del Mundo - Patagonia Reserva del Fin del Mundo Familia Schroeder - Patagonia Saurus Patagonia Select

18 Bodega NQN - Viñedos de la Patagonia srl Bodegas Esmeralda sa (Argento) Malma Reserva Argento Finca Sophenia SA Altosur Santos J Carelli sa Carelli Bodegas San Huberto San Huberto Crianza Cabernet Vistandes sa Viña Famatina Cabernet Bodegas Esmeralda sa (Argento) Argento Cabernet Santos J Carelli sa Latitud 34 Cabernet Finca Flichman Finca Flichman Reserva Viña Funcación de Mendoza SA Fundación de Mendoza Cabernet Prestigio Lagarde SA Altas Cumbres Cabernet Finca La Celia SA La Consulta Cabernet Viña Doña Paula Doña Paula Estate Cabernet Bodegas Santa Ana Santa Ana Cabernet Reserve Finca Don Carlos sa Calathus La Esperanza sa Finca El Origen Reserva Establecimientos Vitivinicolas Escorihuela Candela

19 Mendoza Vineyards sa Mendoza Vineyards Reserve Vistandes sa Alto Las Tacas Bodega Dante Robino Dante Robino Finca La Celia SA Piedra del Aguila Finca La Celia SA La Consulta Bodega Trapiche Trapiche Oak Cask Pascual Toso sa Pascual Toso Reserva Viniterra sa Viniterra Select Finca Flichman Expresiones /Cabernet Atilio Avena e Hijos sa Araucal Bodega NQN - Viñedos de la Patagonia srl Colección NQN Bodega Colome sa Colome Estate Bodega Nofal - Familia Nofal Alonso sa Bodega y Viñedos Mauricio Lorca Nofal Alonzo Blend Opalo Eral Bravo Winery Urano Finca La Celia SA La Celia Bodega Tamarí sa Tamarí Reserve Bodega & Viñedos Domiciano de Barrancas Domiciano de Barrancas Kaiken SA Kaiken Bodega Nieto Senetiner Don Nicador

20 Tittarelli VOSA (Part of Agroamerican Group sa) Reserva de Familia Bodega Tamarí sa Tamarí Viñas del Adagio SA Brumales Nomade Wines and Vineyards 7 Lunas Finca Lunlunta SA La Chamiza Polo Amateur Shiraz Santos J Carelli sa Latitud 34 Syrah Ovalles-Muñoz srl Ovalles & Muñoz Syrah Santiago Graffigna Graffigna Syrah Santiago Graffigna Graffigna Centenario Syrah Finca Las Moras Las Moras Reserve Shiraz Bodegas Santa Ana La Mascota Bodega Catena Zapata Tilia Don Cristobal Cristobal Oak Reserve Bodega Trapiche Trapiche Broquel Telteca Winery (Viñas Argentinas sa) Telteca Viña Las Perdices sa Las Perdices Bodega y Viñedos San Polo sa Auka Bodega Ruca Malen SA Ruca Malen J & F Lurton Argentina Gran Lurton

21 Bodega Luigi Bosca Luigi Bosca Gala 2 Cabernet Bodega Colome sa Colome Estate Bodega Noemia de Patagonia sa A Lisa Bodega Antigal sa Antigal 1 Bodega y Viñedos San Polo sa Bodegas El Porvenir de Los Andes Auka Reserva Laborum Bodega Melipal Melipal Reserve Bodega Trapiche Trapiche Single Vineyard Viña Carlos Gei Berra Finca La Celia SA Piedra del Aguila Syrah Finca Lunlunta SA La Chamiza Polo Profesional Syrah Eral Bravo Winery Urano Syrah Bodegas Viñas de Altura sa Santa Luisa Syrah Mendoza Vineyards sa Shiraz Carancho Reserve Freixenet Argentina sa Viento Sur Syrah Nomade Wines and Vineyards Nomade Reserva Syrah Vistandes sa Gradum Marta's Vineyard Marta's Vinyard Signature Private Collection Bodega Ruca Malen SA Kinien Establecimientos Vitivinicolas Escorihuela Candela President's Blend

22 La Riojana Cooperative Vitivinifruticola de La Rioja Ltda Raza Argentina Limited Edition Viñas del Adagio SA Adagio Estiba Reservada Freixenet Argentina sa Sergio Traverso Gran Reserva Freixenet Argentina sa [ñ] Viñas del Adagio SA Adagio Premium Vinorum srl Vinorum Reserve Mendel Mendel